Pencil stub
Nine files on how mediums and mentalists work, from suggestion and the séance to forces, billets, codes and the act, and how to start practising every method yourself.
Think of a single digit, from zero to nine. Keep it.
Don’t write it down and don’t change it. The book comes back to it at the end.
Mind-reading is a performance built from small, learnable skills
Steering a choice, gathering information in secret, passing it on and hiding the method. None of it is supernatural, and every part of it can be practised.
Every entry is an effect, a method, a practice and a tag
This book is about method and practice, so it uses a light label rather than a grade. The question it answers is simple: is there a study behind this, is it something performers rely on, or is it something people merely believe?
Two rules run through the collection
The second rule belongs to this volume. An audience that sees a miracle looks for a miraculous cause, and the method is nearly always smaller and duller than anyone guesses: a peek, a force, a list of what most people have in common. The first belongs to Hand Lens, and holds here too: every skill in these files is built a few minutes a day, with a test you cannot fool.
Would they still enjoy it if they knew how it was done?
The test is the performer’s version of a publicity test. Would the audience still enjoy the effect if they knew it was a trick, and would they still pay for it? If the answer is no, the method has stopped being a performance.
The Medium
Tables that tilt, hands that seem to know the way, suggestion that works on the willing, and the theatre of the dark room.
CONTACT
Think hard about a movement and your muscles begin to make it, too slightly to feel. Pendulums, tables, dowsing rods and muscle readers all run on that.
Think of a movement and your hand starts to make it
A ring on a thread, held still over a drawn cross, swings along the line you are thinking of. It feels as if something else is moving it.
The pendulum
Draw a cross and label one line YES, the other NO. Hold a ring or a key on a thread, elbow on the table, the weight just above the centre.
The table, the board and the rod move the same way
09.2. Faraday fitted a light lever between the sitters’ hands and the table. Shown the pointer, they could not turn the table at all. Hidden, it showed their hands pushing first (Faraday, 1853). Try it: lay loose card under your hands, mark its edge, and see which moves first.
In facilitated communication, the helper’s hand did the typing
A non-speaking person, hand supported by a helper, seemed to type fluent messages. Families heard someone they loved speak at last.
Hold the wrist, walk, and let their tension steer you
Blindfolded, you lead a friend across a room and stop at the object they hid, holding only their wrist.
The guide’s arm says no long before it says yes
Muscle reading is mostly the reading of refusals. Every wrong turn meets a little drag. The right line feels like nothing at all.
Find it without touching, by reading the guide behind you
You walk ahead, the guide follows a step behind without touching you, and you still stop at the hidden object.
Count slowly, and stop when they relax
A friend thinks of a number from one to 20. You count aloud, or tap the table, and stop on their number.
Guess which hand holds the coin from gaze, shoulder and grip
A friend hides a coin in one fist behind their back, brings both fists forward, and you name the right hand more often than chance.
Which hand?
A friend hides a coin in one hand behind their back and brings both fists forward. You name a hand. Repeat it 50 times.
Contact, in practice
Five habits for working with the ideomotor effect, on yourself and on others. The first is the one that protects you from fooling yourself, which is how most of the people in this file were fooled.
SUGGESTION
A suggestion works best on someone who expects it to. Stage hypnotists find those people first, then let the stage and the audience do much of the rest.
In 1784 a blindfold showed that magnetism was imagination
Mesmer’s patients fell into convulsive “crises” when magnetised. Paris believed a fluid passed from healer to patient.
Suggestibility can be measured, and most people sit in the middle
Read the same 10 suggestions to a hall of people and they spread out: a few respond to almost nothing, a few to nearly everything.
Most people are somewhat suggestible. Very few are highly so.
About one in seven passed half or more. In a full theatre, that is plenty for a stage show.
A stage hypnotist auditions the audience before hypnotising anyone
From a full house, the hypnotist ends up with a handful of volunteers who respond to everything, and nobody watching saw the choosing.
The hand clasp
For one friend who has agreed to try it. They clasp their hands, fingers interlocked, arms out in front, and squeeze.
On stage, the wish to play along does much of the work
Volunteers bark, dance and forget their own names. Afterwards some say they could not help it. Others say they simply went along.
Suggestion works almost as well without hypnosis
People told to imagine an arm growing heavy respond nearly as much wide awake as after a formal induction.
Learn three waking-suggestion stunts that need no trance
A friend’s fingers drift together on their own, a hand sticks to the table, and an imagined book grows too heavy to hold.
Hypnotic language patterns are good patter, not a hidden lever
Courses promise that commands hidden inside ordinary sentences will make people act without noticing.
Hypnosis makes memories more confident, not more accurate
Under hypnosis, witnesses recall more detail and feel sure of it. Police have used it to refresh witnesses’ memories.
Remove every suggestion, and never work on the vulnerable
A show where every volunteer walks off exactly as they came on, and the venue keeps its licence.
Suggestion, in practice
Five rules for anyone who uses suggestion, on stage or among friends. The third and fourth are the ones the law and the research insist on.
SÉANCE
Every classic séance effect was built for the dark, and most of them were exposed the first time somebody was allowed to look.
The first spirit raps were a girl’s toe joints
In 1848, in Hydesville, New York, raps answered questions in the Fox family’s house. Modern spiritualism grew from them.
The Davenport tie leaves slack that two people can share
Two brothers, roped hand and foot in a cabinet, made bells ring and instruments play as soon as the doors closed. Opened, they were still tied.
Tables, slates and photographs: three staples, three methods
11.3. Tipping starts with the ideomotor pushes of entry 09.2. Mediums helped. Watchers hidden under the chairs saw Eusapia Palladino slide her toe under a table leg and lift it, her hand pressing down on top to make a clamp (Houdini, 1924).
In the dark, two sitters can end up holding one hand
Every sitter holds a neighbour’s hand. The medium is “controlled” on both sides, yet a bell rings across the room and a cold hand touches a cheek.
One hand on two neighbours frees the other for the bell
The grip the sitters believe in, and the grip they actually have.
After a séance, sitters remember things that never happened
Sitters leave sure that the table rose, though it never moved. Their accounts become the evidence.
What you cannot see in the dark
A sitter’s account: the table rose, a bell rang by the cabinet, a cold hand touched my cheek, and a message appeared on a sealed slate. Name each method, then lift the bar.
Houdini spent his last years exposing mediums
The best-known escape artist of his day sat with mediums, then reproduced their effects on stage and in print.
Return five objects to their owners by secret marks
Five people each seal a small personal object in an envelope. The envelopes are mixed. You read each object and hand it back to its owner.
Stage a séance as a ghost story, never as real contact
A dark room, a story, a table that tips and a bell that rings. Guests enjoy the fright and leave knowing it was a show.
The séance, in practice
Five rules for the dark room, whether you are running a séance or sitting at one. The last is the performer’s rule in its plainest form.
The Performer
The machinery of a mind-reading act: how a choice is steered, how secret information is gathered, the principles that do the work, codes, and presentation.
FORCES
A force gives someone a free choice whose result you knew in advance. The craft is making each step feel like their decision, then letting memory tidy the steps away.
Ask for a digit, and most people reach for the same one
You name the digit a stranger has just thought of, far more often than one time in 10.
Ask for a card, and the Ace of Spades comes up most
You name a card someone merely thought of, and you are right far more often than one time in 52.
A vague category gets a predictable answer
Asked for a vegetable, a flower or a piece of furniture, a stranger names the word in your sealed envelope.
Words and gestures can steer a card without anyone noticing
A spectator names the three of diamonds, a card almost nobody names unprompted, and believes it was a free thought.
Four small gestures put one card at the top of the list
People pictured a card while a performer gestured. With no gestures, nobody named the target.
In the equivoque, a choice means whatever you need it to mean
A spectator makes free choices among objects on the table and ends with the one you predicted.
Equivoque branches
Three coins on the table; the target is the middle one. Say each line as if it were the only plan.
Time the spread or the riffle, and the card is already chosen
A spectator touches, or stops you at, a card “anywhere” in the deck. It is the one you planned.
Three kinds of force that need no sleight of hand
Cross-cut: force card on top. They cut off half and set the rest across it. Talk, lift the top packet and point to “the card you cut to”: the old top card. Hindu shuffle: force card on the bottom. Pull small packets off the top until they say stop, then show the bottom of what you still hold.
Leave a gap, and the method falls out of the memory
A week later, a spectator tells friends they chose a card freely from a deck you never touched.
Forcing, in practice
A force fails in two ways: the spectator sees the procedure, or the procedure misses. Every rule here guards against one or the other, and the log guards against fooling yourself.
BILLETS
A billet is a small slip of paper with something secret written on it. The performer never seems to read it, and reads it anyway, usually long before the reveal.
Fold every billet the same way, so you know where the writing is
Whatever the spectator writes, you can find, steal or read it in a second, because it always sits in the same place.
Tear the billet to pieces, and keep the one piece that matters
You tear the spectator’s folded billet into pieces and burn them. Later, you name what they wrote.
The centre tear
A square slip, a circle in the middle, and a word written inside it. Follow the figure.
Swap their billet for a blank, and read theirs at leisure
The spectator’s folded billet is burnt in full view. You read it anyway, because what burnt was a blank.
With a swami, the prediction is written after the answer
A prediction written “before” the spectator chose matches their free answer.
Read what they write from the top of the pencil
A spectator writes a digit at the far side of the table, paper hidden. You name it.
Each digit makes its own movement at the top of the pencil
The pencil top copies each stroke, larger and less tidy. The start, the direction and the lifts tell the digits apart.
Read the pencil
These are the paths a pencil top made while someone wrote a three-digit number.
Writing on the top sheet is pressed into the next one
A spectator writes on a pad, tears off the sheet and keeps it. You still know what they wrote.
Announce the billet you just opened while holding up the next
You hold each folded billet to your forehead, name what is inside, then open it to confirm. Every one is right.
Envelopes leak, stages collect, and people show you their writing
Paper wetted with spirit turns translucent and clears as it dries, which is the principle behind sold peek sprays. A strong torch behind a thin envelope does much the same with no kit. A window envelope has a cut panel on the side the performer holds.
Billet work, in practice
Every billet method rests on the same two habits: control the paper from the start, and take the peek at a moment nobody will remember. The reveal comes much later, when the paper seems long gone.
PRINCIPLES
Some of the strongest effects in mentalism need no sleight at all. A stacked deck, a shuffle that cannot mix colours, a sum that always comes out the same: the secret is arithmetic.
Find any card by the card you know beside it
A card is chosen, returned and lost in a cut deck. You find it.
In the Si Stebbins stack, every card is three more than the last
A deck is cut freely. You glimpse one card and name the next, or name the card someone cut to without seeing it.
What’s the next card?
Add three to the value. Move the suit on one: clubs, hearts, spades, diamonds, then clubs again.
Memorise one stack, and every card has a number
You name the 37th card of a deck that has just been cut, or say where any named card lies.
One riffle shuffle cannot separate red–black pairs
A spectator shuffles the deck. You deal it in pairs, and every pair is one red card and one black.
After one riffle, every pair still holds one of each colour
Set 16 cards red, black, red, black. Deal half into a pile, riffle once, then read them off in twos.
Two counting paths through a deck usually end on one card
A spectator picks a secret number and counts through a shuffled deck by a rule. You name the card they finish on.
Some sums come out the same whatever number goes in
A spectator picks any three-digit number and does some arithmetic in private. Your sealed prediction says 1089.
Five cards of numbers reveal any choice from 1 to 31
A spectator thinks of a number from 1 to 31 and says which of five cards it appears on. You name it at once.
Build a magic square for any total in under 2 minutes
A spectator names a number. You fill a 4 × 4 grid in which every row, column and diagonal adds to it.
A book test forces a page and a word that seem freely chosen
A spectator reaches a page by their own arithmetic and thinks of one word on it. You name the word.
Name the weekday of any date with the Doomsday rule
Someone gives you a date, such as their birthday. You name the day of the week in a few seconds.
Doomsday
Find the weekday of 25 December 2026, using the chart.
Self-working principles, in practice
A self-working principle is only as good as the set-up behind it and the story in front of it. The arithmetic is never the part the audience should notice.
CODES
Two-person telepathy is a conversation with a second meaning. One partner talks, and the other listens for a few ordinary words that carry digits, letters and objects.
Robert-Houdin trained his son’s eye before he built the code
In Paris in 1846, a blindfolded 12-year-old named each object handed to his father, down to a cloth merchant’s thread counter.
Give each digit a cue word, and spell with pairs of digits
Your partner, blindfolded or out of sight, names the number, the word or the object you are holding.
Ten everyday words carry every digit, and two carry every letter
Learn the digits until each word is automatic, then the letters: A is 01, Z is 26. The billet on the title slide is written in this code.
Decode the message
A performer holds up something borrowed from a spectator and says to a blindfolded partner: “Right. Right, well, go on. Now, go on. Right… concentrate.” What is it?
Let the length of a silence carry the number
Your partner names a digit that was chosen while neither of you said a word.
Where you stand and how your hands rest can carry a signal
From the back of the room you send a colour, a suit or a number to a partner on stage, without moving your lips.
The Zancigs played telepathy for years, then described the code
Julius walked through the audience. Agnes, on stage, named objects and read notes. They were billed as “Two Minds With But a Single Thought”.
The Piddingtons never explained their act, and nobody has proved how
On BBC radio from 1949, Lesley named items chosen in a London studio while she was held elsewhere: in a diving bell, or under guard in the Tower of London.
Every blindfold leaks beside the nose
Blindfolded, with coins or dough taped over your eyes, you name objects, read a card or walk between chairs.
Build the act in stages: objects, then numbers, then cards
With a partner you run a five-minute act: borrowed objects named, a serial number read, a thought-of card revealed.
Codes, in practice
Every rule here comes back to the standing order. The code has to pass as conversation for a whole evening, so it is learned until it is automatic, spoken as small talk and kept clean of accidental cue words.
SHOWTIME
A method is not an act. What an audience keeps is one clear effect, done by a believable character, in an order that builds, with nobody made a fool of.
Say the effect in one sentence before you learn the method
Someone who saw your act can retell each effect in one sentence, and the sentence sounds impossible.
One sentence, no “and then”
Pick an effect from Files 12 to 15. Describe it in one sentence of under 20 words, as a spectator would tell a friend the next day.
Play a character, and let the character explain the effects
The audience believes in the performer, because the performer is one consistent person with a reason for what they can do.
Manage what each witness sees, and look after the volunteer
Dual reality works because the audience assumes the volunteer saw what they saw. The volunteer knows, so use it only where they will enjoy being in on it. Ortiz (1994) treats conditions and convincers apart; the best convincers seem to happen by accident. Both close off explanations before the reveal.
Choose your frame: psychic, psychological, or plainly a show
The same trick reads as a miracle, a skill or a story, depending on the one sentence that comes before it.
Open short and clear, build, and close on the strongest effect
Three effects feel like one act that rises to an ending, not three tricks in a row.
A routine rises in steps and ends on its peak
Three effects, each stronger than the last. A small, planned miss before the climax makes it look hard won. Then stop.
Script five minutes
Choose three effects from this book: one quick, one with a volunteer, one prediction in view from the start. Write every word you will say.
Plan a small miss, and rehearse what you do after a real one
After a near-miss, the next hit feels hard won. A real miss passes almost unnoticed, because the act moves straight on.
Two teenage magicians fooled a well-funded psychic research lab
From 1979, a new university laboratory tested two young “psychics” for metal bending and telepathy, and recorded many successes.
When the host supplies the props, the feats may not appear
In 1973 Uri Geller, famous for bending spoons, appeared on The Tonight Show. In 22 minutes he performed none of his feats.
Would they still enjoy it if they knew it was a trick?
An act that stays a pleasure once the method is known, and never costs anyone money, trust or peace of mind.
Showtime, in practice
Five habits that turn a set of methods into an act. Each one keeps attention on the effect and the people in it, and off the method.
The Audience
Why every method in this volume works on the mind: attention, memory and the urge to find a fit.
MIND
Every method in this book relies on how an audience attends, remembers and decides.
Do the work where the attention is not
The audience watches closely and still never sees the moment the method happens.
Misdirection works on three parts of the mind
Magicians have classified misdirection by what the performer does. Psychologists sorted it by the part of the audience’s mind it acts on.
The trick they remember is not the trick you did
A week later, the spectator describes an effect that you could not have done.
Retell it
Perform one simple effect for a friend who has agreed to help. A week later, ask them to tell it to someone else while you listen.
The listener turns a vague line into a personal one
A statement that fits most people feels as if it was written for one.
People test a belief by looking for what fits it
A sitter remembers the lines that fitted and forgets the ones that missed.
A reward that comes by chance still trains a ritual
People credit a habit, a charm or a pendulum with results that arrived on their own.
A thought just before an act makes it feel chosen
A spectator feels they freely chose what the performer steered, and a sitter feels the glass move by itself.
People defend choices they never made
A spectator explains why they chose a card, a face or a flavour that was swapped after they chose it.
Belief, suggestion and the crowd shape what people report
17.8. An actor suggested a séance table was rising when it stayed still. About a third of sitters later said it had moved, believers more often, and only when the suggestion fitted their belief (Wiseman et al., 2003). File 11 relies on this.
The audience’s mind, in practice
The first three are the performer’s side of this file. The last two keep the performer honest: the habits of mind that make an audience see a miracle also make a performer believe a method works better than it does.
Nine rules, one for each file
Each house rule is the shortest form of its file. They are also the lines on the statement posters, so the wall and the book say the same thing.
At the start you thought of a digit. The billet says .
The folded note on the title slide has held its prediction since the first page. File 15’s code turns its patter into the word.
Also on the bill
Volume One, Hand Lens: reading people, deduction, cold and hot reading, memory systems, observation, reading speed and the myths about minds.
Every entry in this guide is indexed, with its definition, at https://www.geraldajam.com/library/glossary/field-guides/pencil-stub.